Molecular biological processes play an essential role in human development. Universal screening for prevalent barriers seen in that practice; facilitate, track, and follow-up on referrals offered. The Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACE) Study, The enduring effects of abuse and related adverse experiences in childhood. Conversely, early supports that allow new mothers more opportunities to bond with, breastfeed, and simply stroke their children are associated with decreases in the methylation of the glucocorticoid receptor gene, perhaps allowing infants to downregulate their stress responses more effectively.78,79 This finding is one of the most significant predictions of the ecobiodevelopmental model: the biological mechanisms that underlie the embedding of significant childhood adversity may also underlie the embedding of positive relational experiences in childhood. Maternal distress mediated links between environmental chaos and children's mental health. "The . It was heralded as a good thing. These perspectives offer different interpretations of the nature of society and the role of . POTENTIAL CONFLICT OF INTEREST: The authors have indicated they have no potential conflicts of interest to disclose. The ecobiodevelopmental framework asserts that the ecology becomes biologically embedded, and there is an ongoing but cumulative dance between the ecology and the biology that drives development over the life span. A public health approach to promoting relational health should also be integrated horizontally (or across sectors) at the local level.81,82,148 SSNRs are easier to form when safe, stable, and nurturing families are able to live in safe, stable, and nurturing communities.124,149,150 The FCPMH is ideally placed to educate families about what a safe, stable, and nurturing family environment looks like for a child, but doing so will require changes at the provider and practice levels (see Table 2). Part 1 - Overview of Developmental Domains, Periods, and Theories a. Domains of Development b. Efforts to repair strained or compromised relationships are likely to be more effective if other potential barriers to SSNRs are being addressed (eg, parental mental illness and basic needs) and additional efforts are being made to actively promote SSNRs (eg, the provision of developmentally appropriate play). Eco-biodevelopmental models are advocated by the American Academy of Pediatrics, and these models offer insights into the neurobiological processes associated with environmental factors and the ways in which these processes may be addressed to improve outcomes. It calls for pediatricians to serve as both front-line guardians of healthy child development and strategically positioned, community leaders to inform new science-based strategies that build strong foundations for . But those same biological changes could prove to be maladaptive, toxic, and health harming over time.10,11. Bronfenbrenner's theory explains that there are certain cultural and social factors in the immediate environment of a child affect child development and experience. Unfortunately, the two theories are very much at odds regarding what is "right." Shareholder theory asserts that shareholders advance capital to a company's managers, who are supposed to spend corporate funds only in ways that have been authorized by the shareholders. (2) Challenge to Dominant Ideology: CRT challenges the claims of neutrality, objectivity, colorblindness, and meritocracy in society. BStC, biological sensitivity to context; PTSD, posttraumatic stress disorder. Doing so will require all trainees to address their implicit biases, develop cultural humility, and provide culturally competent recommendations. The strongest factor determining how involved a father is in nurturing and providing physical care, cognitive activities and warmth with an infant is: how important he feels his contribution is Nick's (15 months old) parents often didn't respond when he tried to communicate to them. Typically, restorative justice allows the victims and the offenders to mediate a restitution agreement that is satisfactory to both parties. The American Academy of Pediatrics has neither solicited nor accepted any commercial involvement in the development of the content of this publication. See the Appendix for full descriptions of the abbreviations. In the case of toxic stress responses, universal primary prevention means trying to prevent the precipitants of toxic stress responses (eg, advocating to address the spectrum of adversities discussed above) as well as promote healthy, adaptive responses to adversity through the provision of social supports that nurture the development of foundational resilience skills (such as task persistence, curiosity, and self-regulation).16,19,59,83, A public health approach to prevent childhood toxic stress is a public health approach to promote relational health. 7. Ecological includes experiences in a child's home environment, such as reading, talking, teaching,. The toxic stress framework may help to define many of our most intractable problems at a biological level, but a relational health framework helps to define the much-needed solutions at the individual, familial, and community levels (see Table 1). For children who are symptomatic or meet criteria for toxic stress-related diagnoses (eg, anxiety, oppositional defiant disorder, or posttraumatic stress), indicated, evidence-based therapies are needed. The second assumption is that the FCPMH will have the capacity to form working relationships with a wide array of community partners. Andrew Garner, Michael Yogman; COMMITTEE ON PSYCHOSOCIAL ASPECTS OF CHILD AND FAMILY HEALTH, SECTION ON DEVELOPMENTAL AND BEHAVIORAL PEDIATRICS, COUNCIL ON EARLY CHILDHOOD, Preventing Childhood Toxic Stress: Partnering With Families and Communities to Promote Relational Health. Tertiary preventions in the relational health framework are focused on the evidence-based practices such as ABC, CPP, or PCIT that repair strained relationships and assist them in becoming more safe, stable, and nurturing. For children deemed to be at high risk for toxic stress responses, potential barriers to relational health need to be identified and addressed through team-based care144 and collaborative community partnerships (eg, food banks,145,146 medical-legal partnerships147). Without strong therapeutic alliances with patients, caregivers, and families, few of the recommended universal primary preventions will be implemented, few of the targeted interventions will be used, and few of the indicated treatments will be sought. Relational health is a strengths-based approach because it is focused on solutions: those individual, family, and community capacities that promote SSNRs, buffer adversity, and build resilience. The 3 principles described above, each of which is grounded in the research literature, provide a science-based framework for developing innovative strategies to promote SSNRs at the dyadic level, family level, and community level. HealthySteps is an evidence-based, interdisciplinary pediatric primary care program that promotes positive parenting and healthy development for infants and toddlers, with an emphasis on families living in low-income communities. Asserting that adults with core life skills are essential, not only to form and maintain SSNRs with children but also to scaffold and develop the basic social and emotional skills that enable children to be resilient and flourish despite adversity. Learning Objective: Describe the structure and function of genes. But underlying this approach are 2 fundamental assumptions. ACEs are common stressful traumatic experiences which affect children's neurodevelopment. Posted on June 1, 2022 by A Comparison of the Toxic Stress and Relational Health Frameworks. Implement home visiting; support extended family medical leave. More importantly, they are rarely integrated vertically with other programs that layer on additional efforts to address barriers to relational health (eg, SDoHs) or already strained or compromised relationships (eg, PCIT) when needed. An evolutionary-developmental theory of the origins and functions of stress reactivity, Risky decision making from childhood through adulthood: contributions of learning and sensitivity to negative feedback, Biological sensitivity to context moderates the effects of the early teacher-child relationship on the development of mental health by adolescence, Links between shared reading and play, parent psychosocial functioning, and child behavior: evidence from a randomizedcontrolled trial, Attendance at well-child visits after Reach Out and Read, Reach Out and Read: evidence based approach to promoting early child development, Triple P-Positive Parenting Program as a public health approach to strengthening parenting, Maintenance of treatment gains: a comparison of enhanced, standard, and self-directed Triple P-Positive Parenting Program, Home visiting and the biology of toxic stress: opportunities to address early childhood adversity, Guiding principles for team-based pediatric care, Training pediatric residents in a primary care clinic to help address psychosocial problems and prevent child maltreatment, Linking urban families to community resources in the context of pediatric primary care, Medical-legal strategies to improve infant health care: a randomized trial, Applying a 3.0 transformation framework to guide large-scale health system reform. In the past decade or so, biomedical researchers have proposed an ecobiodevelopmental framework for studying health and disease across the life course . Stability of tenure: This principle says employees must have job security to be efficient. ancillary support services (interpretation, telemedicine, transportation, etc) enabling youth with special health care needs to access the many layers of support that they frequently require. The American Academy of Pediatrics asserts that SSNRs are biological necessities for all children because they mitigate childhood toxic stress responses and proactively build resilience by fostering the adaptive skills needed to cope with future adversity in a healthy manner. 10.1542/peds.2021-052582. Domains, timing, and intensity of chaos were predictive of children's mental and physical health. To move forward (to proactively build healthy, resilient children), the pediatric community needs to embrace the concept of relational health.15 Relational health refers to the ability to form and maintain SSNRs, as these are potent antidotes for childhood adversity and toxic stress responses.57,113 Not only do SSNRs buffer adversity and turn potentially toxic stress responses into tolerable or positive responses, but they are also the primary vehicle for building the foundational resilience skills that allow children to cope with future adversity in an adaptive, healthy manner.16,17 These findings highlight the need for multigenerational approaches that support parents and adults as they, in turn, provide the SSNRs that all children need to flourish. University of Utah, Department of Psychology, College of Social & Behavioral Science. Relational health explains how the individual, family, and community capacities that support the development and maintenance of SSNRs also buffer adversity and build resilience across the life course. These varied adversities share the potential to trigger toxic stress responses and inhibit the formation of SSNRs. With almost a century of service to children, families, and communities, the field of pediatrics has made critical contributions at the interface of science and public policy. Driving this transformation are advances in developmental sciences as they inform a deeper understanding of how early life experiences, both nurturing and adverse, are biologically embedded and influence outcomes in health, education, and economic stability across the life span. Adapted with permission from Garner AS, Saul RA. To prevent childhood toxic stress responses and support optimal development across the life span, the promotion of relational health needs to become an integral component of pediatric care and a primary objective for pediatric research and advocacy. Toxic stress explains how many of our societys most intractable problems (disparities in health, education, and economic stability) are rooted in our shared biology but divergent experiences and opportunities. Acknowledge that a wide range of adversities, from discrete, threatening events to ongoing, chronic life conditions, share the potential to trigger toxic stress responses and inhibit the formation of SSNRs. Contact your SAGE representative to request a demo. Understand the relational health framework, which explains how the individual, family, and community capacities that support the development and maintenance of SSNRs also buffer adversity and build resilience across the life course (see Table 1). See the Appendix for full descriptions of the abbreviations. Prepare residents to work as part of the interdisciplinary teams144 that transform FCPMHs into hubs for medical neighborhoods.161. Still other techniques keep the discussion focused, practical, and organized. Three indicators of flourishing are amenable to parental report and are rough markers of executive function: (1) the child shows interest and curiosity in learning new things, (2) the child works to finish tasks he or she starts, and (3) the child stays calm and in control when faced with a challenge.59 In analyses of data from the 20162017 National Survey of Childrens Health, the prevalence of flourishing children increased in a graded fashion with increasing levels of family resilience and connection.59 In fact, a higher percentage of children with high adversity (ACE scores 49) but high family connection and resilience were flourishing (30.5%) than children with low adversity (ACE score of 0) but low family resilience and connection (26.8%).59 Approaches to minimizing toxic stress that only look at measures of adversity (such as ACE scores or biomarkers) will miss out on opportunities to support the relational health that promotes flourishing despite adversity. This principle points to the potential benefits of addressing stressors from across the spectrum of adversity, including those that might have been considered well beyond the scope of traditional pediatric practice in the past. Employ a vertically integrated public health approach to promote relational health that is founded on universal primary preventions (such as positive parenting programs, ROR, and developmentally appropriate play) but also offers more precise screening for relational health barriers (such as maternal depression, food insecurity, or exposure to racism) as well as indicated treatments to repair strained or compromised relationships (such as ABC, CPP, PCIT, and TF-CBT). Acronym for the social determinants of health; SDoHs refer to conditions where people live, learn, work, and play (like socioeconomic status, social capital, or exposure to discrimination or community violence) that are known to affect health outcomes across the life span. The buffering and skill-building roles of responsive relationships are biologically embedded, and they are essential promoters of healthy development.59 Existing AAP reports on managing perinatal depression,90 supporting grieving children,195 fostering male caregiver engagement,196 partnering with home visiting programs,142 encouraging developmentally appropriate play,74,197 discouraging screen time,125 and promoting shared-book reading67,68 include additional recommendations on ways primary care pediatricians might promote SSNRs. ecobiodevelopmental (EBD) framework to stimulate fresh thinking about the promotion of health and prevention of disease across the lifespan. Emphasizing that the vertical integration of this public health approach or the layering of primary, secondary, and tertiary preventions and/or interventions is necessary because the heterogeneity of responses to adversity seen at the population level will need to be addressed through a menu of programs that are layered and matched to specific levels of individual need (universal preventions, plus targeted interventions for those at risk, plus indicated therapies for those with symptoms or diagnoses). Identify and address potential barriers to SSNRs. That said, the toxic stress framework is a problem-focused model because it is focused on what happens biologically in the absence of mitigating social and emotional buffers. For example, significant adversity in the last trimester of pregnancy is associated with methylation of the childs glucocorticoid receptor gene.76 In adults, the methylation of this gene is associated with the expression of fewer glucocorticoid receptors in the brain.5 Because cortisol downregulates its own production via negative feedback loops in the brain that use glucocorticoid receptors, children with fewer glucocorticoid receptors would be expected to have higher cortisol levels and be more irritable and harder to console.77 These changes could be considered adaptive and beneficial in the short-term because they might prepare the newborn infant for a stressful world in which the infant may need to be more vocal to have his or her needs met. Acronym for safe, stable, and nurturing relationships; these allow the child to feel protected, connected, and competent. Foremost on the advocacy agenda will be the need for serious payment reforms that consider the complexity of care attributable to adverse family and community contexts and include financial supports that incentivize families to engage with an FCPMH.204 Payment reforms need to be sufficient to allow FCPMHs to spend more time with families, function as interdisciplinary teams, integrate into their communitys initiatives and services to support children and families (horizontal integration), and anchor medical neighborhoods that not only foster wellness in childhood but promote positive outcomes across the life span. In the original ACE Study, 10 categories of adversity were examined: emotional, physical, and sexual abuse; 5 measures of household dysfunction, including the mother being treated violently (intimate partner violence), household substance abuse, household mental illness, parental separation or divorce, and incarcerated household member; and emotional or physical neglect. Such an approach will require pediatricians, other pediatric health care professionals, and FCPMHs in general to partner with families and communities in practical and innovative ways to universally promote SSNRs, address potential barriers to SSNRs in a targeted manner, and afford indicated treatments that repair relationships that have been strained or compromised (see Table 2). The ecobiodevelopmental model suggests that, to improve the likelihood of positive developmental outcomes across the life span, efforts should be made to improve the salient features of the childs environment. Periods of Development 1. Order: This principle asserts that for an organization to run smoothly, the right person must be in the right job and that, therefore, every material and employee should be given a proper place. A quasi-experimental study (GoWell) of a UK neighbourhood renewal programmes impact on health inequalities, Towards health equity: a framework for the application of proportionate universalism, University College of London Institute of Health Equity, Safe, stable, nurturing relationships break the intergenerational cycle of abuse: a prospective nationally representative cohort of children in the United Kingdom, Building the Brain's Air Traffic Control System: How Early Experiences Shape the Development of Executive Function: Working Paper No. Early childhood behavioral health: can the medical neighborhood move us forward? Social dominance, school bullying, and child health: what are our ethical obligations to the very young? Similarly, advocating for a Health in All Policies approach could advance health equity and minimize family and community distress by addressing the underlying economic inequities.198200 The commitment of the AAP to decreasing family stress is manifest in many of its official statements, including poverty,87,88 racism,166 maternal depression,90 disasters,152,153 father engagement,196 home visiting,142 and the importance of play.74,197, The strengthening of core life skills (eg, executive function and self-regulation) is needed for families and communities to provide well-regulated, nurturing environments. Routine versus catastrophic influences on the developing child, Childhood neglect: the role of the paediatrician, Inside the adverse childhood experience score: strengths, limitations, and misapplications, Interventions to improve cortisol regulation in children: a systematic review, Rethinking evidence-based practice and two-generation programs to create the future of early childhood policy, Family resilience and connection promote flourishing among US children, even amid adversity, Biological pathways for historical trauma to affect health: A conceptual model focusing on epigenetic modifications, The impact of historical trauma on health outcomes for indigenous populations in the USA and Canada: a systematic review, Promotion of positive parenting and prevention of socioemotional disparities, Primary care strategies for promoting parent-child interactions and school readiness in at-risk families: the Bellevue Project for Early Language, Literacy, and Education Success, Parenting skills and emotional availability: an RCT, Beyond the ACE score: examining relationships between timing of developmental adversity, relational health and developmental outcomes in children, Reading aloud, play, and social-emotional development, The pediatricians role in optimizing school readiness, Literacy promotion: an essential component of primary care pediatric practice, Early childhood investments substantially boost adult health, Depressive symptoms in young adults: the influences of the early home environment and early educational child care, Lifetime Effects: the High/Scope Perry Preschool Study Through Age 40, Enhancing parent talk, reading, and play in primary care: sustained impacts of the video interaction project, Integrating a parenting intervention with routine primary health care: a cluster randomized trial, COMMITTEE ON PSYCHOSOCIAL ASPECTS OF CHILD AND FAMILY HEALTH, The power of play: a pediatric role in enhancing development in young children, Thinking developmentally: the next evolution in models of health, Maternal psychosocial stress during pregnancy alters the epigenetic signature of the glucocorticoid receptor gene promoter in their offspring: a meta-analysis, Prenatal exposure to maternal depression, neonatal methylation of human glucocorticoid receptor gene (NR3C1) and infant cortisol stress responses, Effects of prenatal and postnatal depression, and maternal stroking, at the glucocorticoid receptor gene, Epigenetic programming by maternal behavior in the human infant, income inequality and the differential effect of adverse childhood experiences in US children, The changing nature of childrens health development: new challenges require major policy solutions, The health development organization: an organizational approach to achieving child health development, Modifiable resilience factors to childhood adversity for clinical pediatric practice, Healthy Steps for Young Children: sustained results at 5.5 years, Healthy steps in an integrated delivery system: child and parent outcomes at 30 months, Parents adverse childhood experiences and their childrens behavioral health problems, Mediators and adverse effects of child poverty in the United States, Poverty and child health in the United States, Cultures influence on stressors, parental socialization, and developmental processes in the mental health of children of immigrants, Incorporating recognition and management of perinatal depression into pediatric practice, Quality of early family relationships and the timing and tempo of puberty: effects depend on biological sensitivity to context, Biological sensitivity to context: the interactive effects of stress reactivity and family adversity on socioemotional behavior and school readiness, Individual differences in behavioral, physiological, and genetic sensitivities to contexts: implications for development and adaptation, The Orchid and the Dandelion: Why Some Children Struggle and How All Can Thrive, SECTION ON DEVELOPMENTAL AND BEHAVIORAL PEDIATRICS, Addressing early childhood emotional and behavioral problems, Attachment and Biobehavioral Catch-up: an evidence-based intervention for vulnerable infants and their families, Attachment and biobehavioral catch-up: addressing the needs of infants and toddlers exposed to inadequate or problematic caregiving, Enhancing attachment organization among maltreated children: results of a randomized clinical trial, Effectiveness of parent-child interaction therapy (PCIT) in the treatment of young childrens behavior problems.